Skip to Main Content
Paul's Italian logo top Paul's Italian logo scroll
  • (631)-283-1861
  • okie26rashid@yahoo.com
  • 21 Hill Street , Southampton
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Events
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Facebook page Instagram page Yelp page
Paul's Italian logo top Paul's Italian logo scroll
  • Facebook page Instagram page Yelp page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Events
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs

Our Menu

Breakfast Appetizers Entrees Pizza Sandwiches Burgers / Heros Sides / Little Delights Soups / Salads Wraps & Quesadillas Desserts

Farm Fresh Eggs

One Egg Any Style

$5.95

Two Egg Any Style

$7.50

Three Egg Any Style

$9.25

Outrageous Omelettes

Cheese Omelette

$9.25
Perfectly cooked with our fabulous home fries and your choice of cheese.

Western Omelette

$10.95
Sauteed ham, peppers and onions combined with eggs.

All American Omelette

$10.50
Your choice of Bacon, Ham or Sausage with your choice of cheese.
Spinach & Feta Omelette photo

Spinach & Feta Omelette

$10.50

Mushroom, Broccoli & Cheddar

$10.95

Tomato, Onion & Provolone

$10.25

Create Your Own Omelette - Two Items

$10.50

Create Your Own Omelette - Three Items

$11.25

Sandwiches & Things

Egg Sandwiches on a Roll

$3.95

Bacon or Sausage on Roll

$5.95

Egg White Wrap

$9.25
With turkey, Swiss and tomato.

Western Egg Wrap

$9.75
Ham, pepper, onions and cheddar.

American Egg Wrap

$9.25
Ham, bacon and American.

Veggie Egg Wrap

$9.50
Spinach, mushroom and tomato.

Great Griddles

Pancakes

$7.95
3 buttermilk pancakes perfectly cooked.

Short Stack of Pancakes

$6.95
French Toast photo

French Toast

$7.95
3 slices, dipped and cooked delicately.

Short Stack French Toast

$6.95

Steak and Eggs

Steak Cooked to Liking

$15.95
Served with two eggs, our fabulous home fries and choice of toast.

For the Kids

Kid's Pancake

$3.25

Kid's French Toast (Slice)

$2.95

One Egg Kids

$4.50
Any style with toast (home fries included).

Premium

Two Buttermilk Pancakes

$8.95
With two eggs, any style and home fries,

Two French Toast

$9.25
With two eggs, any style and home fries.

Side Orders

Bacon, Ham or Sausage

$5.95

toast

$3.25

English Muffins

$3.25

Hot Appetizers

Fried Zucchini photo

Fried Zucchini

$9.25

Mozzarella Stick

$7.95

Combo Classic

$9.50
Buffalo Wings (Hot, BBQ, Teriyaki) photo

Buffalo Wings (Hot, BBQ, Teriyaki)

$13.50/+
Small $13.50 | Large $23.00

Chicken Fingers

$8.25/+
Small $8.25 | Large $9.95
Garlic Bread photo

Garlic Bread

$4.25

Stir - Fry Vegetable Platter

$15.95

Hot Antipasto

$19.95

Baked Clams Oreganato

$11.95/+
Half Dozen $11.95 | Dozen $18.95

Clams Casino

$12.95/+
Half Dozen $12.95 | Dozen $18.95

Clams Posillipo

$13.95/+
Half Dozen $13.95 | Dozen $17.95

Shrimp Oreganato (3)

$17.95

Shrimp Scampi (3)

$17.95

Shrimp Marinara (3)

$17.95

Shrimp Fra Diavolo (3)

$17.95

Fried Jumbo Shrimp (4)

$18.95
Fried Calamari photo

Fried Calamari

$16.50

Mussels Marinara

$17.50

Mussels Fra Diavolo

$17.50

Mussels Possilipo

$17.25

Steamed Mussels

$15.95

Cold Appetizers

Shrimp Cocktail (4)

$17.25

Clams on the 1/2 Shell

$11.25/+
1/2 dozen $11.25 | Dozen $17.50

Antipasto

$16.50
Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato photo

Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato

$15.50

Pasta Specialties

Pasta with Pesto Sauce

$23.95

Pasta Pomodoro

$18.50

Pasta with Meat Sauce

$19.95

Pasta Marinara

$19.50

Gnocchi

$18.95
With pomodoro.

Cavatelli Pomodoro

$18.95

Penne Alla Vodka

$21.95

Spinach Ravioli with Vodka Sauce

$20.95

Ravioli

$19.50

Baked Ravioli

$21.50

Baked Lasagna

$18.95

Baked Homemade Manicotti

$18.95

Baked Stuffed Shells

$18.95

Baked Ziti Parmigiana

$18.50

Primavera

$23.50
Zucchini, broccoli, carrots, spinach, onion and mushrooms, sauteed in garlic and olive oil.

Aglio & Olio

$19.50
Sauteed garlic and extra virgin olive oil.

Tortellini Alfredo

$23.95

Fettuccine Alfredo

$23.95

Carbonara

$24.50
With imported prosciutto di parma fresh mushroom and onions.

Seafood Specialties

Grilled Salmon photo

Grilled Salmon

$30.95

Salmon Oreganata

$30.95

Fried Flounder Platter

$28.95
Served with lemon & tartar.

Fried Seafood Platter

$28.95/+
For One $28.95 | For Two $53.00 • Delicately fried flounder, scallops, calamari and shrimp.

Steamed Seafood Platter

$28.95/+
For One $28.95 | For Two $53.00
Linguine Clam Sauce photo

Linguine Clam Sauce

$23.95
Fresh local chopped clams in White or Light Red Sauce.

Steamed Clams Over Linguine

$24.95
Fresh local clams steamed in White or Light Red Sauce.

Linguine Marechiare

$30.00
Clams, shrimp and mussels in marinara sauce.
Shrimp Angel Hair photo

Shrimp Angel Hair

$29.95
Shrimp sauteed in our own garlic butter and herbs, served over capellini.

Shrimp Marinara or Fra Diavolo

$29.95
Shrimp sauteed lightly in marinara sauce over linguine.

Calamari Marinara or Fra Diavolo

$26.95
Sauteed in light marinara sauce with white wine, garlic and herbs over linguine.

Mussels Marinara or Fra Diavolo

$25.95
Local mussels sauteed in light marinara sauce with white wine, garlic and herbs over linguine.

Mussels Posillipo

$25.25
Local mussels sauteed with garlic, herbs and white wine over linguine.

Seafood Sizzler

$30.95
Combination of broiled shrimp, fresh flounder and scallops in our oreganata breading, served with a side of Red or White Clam Sauce,

Zuppe De Pesce

$35.95/+
For One $35.95 | For Two $70.00 • Mussels, clams, calamari, shrimp and fresh local flounder sauteed in a delicate fish marinara sauce, served with linguine.

Jumbo Shrimp Oreganato

$29.95
Shrimp broiled in garlic butter and white wine, lightly topped with seasonal bread crumbs.

Jumbo Shrimp Scampi

$29.95
Delicately sauteed in garlic butter.

Jumbo Shrimp Parmigiana

$27.00
Fried shrimp in pomodoro sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

Jumbo Fried Shrimp

$29.95
Fried shrimp served with tartar sauce.

Jumbo Shrimp Francese

$29.95
Delightfully sauteed and served in our white wine and lemon sauce.

Broiled Local Flounder

$28.00
Broiled in flavorful spices and lightly topped with our seasoned bread crumbs.

Italian Classics

Baked Eggplant Parmigiana

$23.50
Breaded eggplant, layered with pomodoro sauce, grated cheese and mozzarella.
Breast of Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana photo

Breast of Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

$25.95
Promodoro sauce and mozzarella with fresh peppers.

Breast of Chicken Marsala

$28.95
Breast of chicken in marsala wine with mushrooms.

Breast of Chicken Piccata

$28.95
Breast of chicken sauteed in white wine with lemon, herbs and prosciutto di parma.

Breast of Chicken Francese

$28.95
Breast of chicken sauteed in butter with white wine and lemon.

Chicken Cacciatore

$23.95
Served with fresh peppers, onion and fresh mushrooms.

Chicken Margherita

$27.95
Sauteed chicken breast with plum tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic, oil, white wine and herbs, topped with fresh mozzarella.

Baked Eggplant Rollatini

$24.95
Breaded eggplant, layered with ricotta pomodoro sauce, grated cheese and mozzarella.

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana

$26.95
Promodoro sauce and mozzarella with fresh peppers.

Veal Scallopine Cacciatore

$28.95
Fresh mushrooms, onions, peppers in a light marinara sauce.

Veal Piccata

$29.95
Veal sauteed in white wine, lemon and herbs with prosciutto di parma.

Veal Francese

$29.95
Veal delicately sauteed in white wine and herbs with lemon.

Veal Marsala

$29.95
Sauteed in marsala wine with mushrooms.

Veal Milanese (Lemon or Pomodoro)

$26.95
Breaded veal cutlet in Italian breadcrumbs.

From the Broiler

Extra Thick Cut Dinner Steak

$30.95

Marinated Extra Thick Cut Dinner Steak

$31.95

Roast Half Chicken

$23.95

Pizza Slices

Cheese Slice

$3.31

Fresh Basil & Mozzarella Slice

$5.20

White Pizza Slice

$4.25
Buffalo Chicken Slice photo

Buffalo Chicken Slice

$5.20
Grandma Slice photo

Grandma Slice

$4.40

Chicken Parm Slice

$4.85
Chicken Caesar Slice photo

Chicken Caesar Slice

$5.20
Chicken Bacon Cheddar Ranch Slice photo

Chicken Bacon Cheddar Ranch Slice

$5.20

Garlic Knots

$1.00

Pizza (Neopolitan)

10″ Cauliflower Pizza

$15.95
With fresh mozzarella & basil with homemade marinara sauce.

Cheese Pizza

$21.75

Shrimp Pizza

$33.25

Fresh Basil & Mozzarella Pizza

$26.75

White Pizza

$27.25

Pesto Plum Pizza

$27.45

Chicken Bacon Cheddar Ranch Pizza

$26.75

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$27.75

Grandma Pizza

$28.50

Paul's Special

$28.00
Sausage, meatball, pepper & onion.

Hampton Garden

$26.75
Broccoli, mushrooms, olives, fresh garlic and artichoke hearts.

Sicilian Pizza

$26.95

10″ Gluten Free Pizza

$15.95

12″ Personal Bar Pizza

$15.75

Chicken Caesar Pizza

$27.95
Calzones photo

Calzones

$9.50

Pan Pizza

Cheese Pan Pizza

$12.25

Veggie Pan Pizza

$14.25
Mushrooms, eggplant, onion and olives.

Seafood Pan Pizza

$17.95
Shrimp & clams,

Deli Sandwiches

Ham Deli Sandwich

$12.50
Comes with lettuce & tomato.

Turkey Deli Sandwich

$12.50
Comes with lettuce & tomato.

Roast Beef Deli Sandwich

$12.50
Comes with lettuce & tomato.

Grilled Pastrami Deli Sandwich

$12.50
Comes with lettuce & tomato.

Chicken Cutlet Deli Sandwich

$12.50
Comes with lettuce & tomato.

Specialty Sandwiches

Ham, Roast Beef, Turkey or Pastrami Melt Sandwich

$13.50
On hero with choice of cheese melted, with lettuce and tomato.

Ham or Roast Beef or Turkey Deluxe Sandwich

$14.95
On hero with bacon, choice of cheese melted, with lettuce and tomato.

Roast Beef Parmagiana Sandwich

$14.50
On garlic bread with mozzarella, lettuce & tomato.
Italian Hero (The Original) Sandwich photo

Italian Hero (The Original) Sandwich

$13.50
Salami, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion and house dressing.

Sea Grinder Sandwich

$13.95
Fresh fillet of flounder with lettuce, tomato and your choice of cheese.
Club Sandwich photo

Club Sandwich

$13.95
Turkey, ham or roast beef with lettuce, tomato and bacon.

Reuben Sandwich

$12.95
Pastrami on rye with Russian dressing and sauerkraut.

The Godfather Sandwich

$13.95
Salami and fresh mozzarella with roasted peppers, shredded lettuce and tomato, sprinkled with house dressing.

The Godmother Sandwich

$15.50
Prosciutto di parma and provolone, with roasted peppers, shredded lettuce and tomato, sprinkled with house dressing.

Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich

$14.95
Sauteed onions and roast beef with cheddar cheese on toasted buttered hero.

Fresh Mozzarella Hero Sandwich

$13.25
Fresh mozzarella, vine-ripe tomatoes, green leaf lettuce, roasted peppers and basil with Italian dressing.

Chicken Avocado Club Sandwich

$13.95
Grilled chicken & avocado with lettuce, tomato & bacon.

Black Russian Sandwich

$13.95
Pastrami, bacon and tomato with swiss cheese and Russian dressing on hero.

Chicken Di Parma Sandwich

$14.95
Chicken cutlet with roasted peppers, prosciutto di parma with melted mozzarella on garlic.

Roast Turkey and Fresh Mozzarella Sandwich

$14.25
Vine-ripe tomatoes with fresh basil and balsamic vinaigrette, served on hero.

Burgers

Hamburger Platter

$10.50
Our 1/2 Lb burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce & tomato, choice of Fries, House Salad, Steamed Vegetables or Baked Potato.
Cheese Burger Platter photo

Cheese Burger Platter

$11.50
Our 1/2 Lb burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce & tomato, choice of Fries, House Salad, Steamed Vegetables or Baked Potato.

Bacon Cheese Burger Platter

$13.25
Our 1/2Lb burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce & tomato, choice of Fries, House Salad, Steamed Vegetables or Baked Potato.

Pizza Burger Platter

$11.95
Our 1/2 Lb burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce & tomato, choice of Fries, House Salad, Steamed Vegetables or Baked Potato.

Turkey Burger Platter

$11.50
Our 1/2 Lb burgers are served on a sesame bun with lettuce & tomato, choice of Fries, House Salad, Steamed Vegetables or Baked Potato.

Heros

Steak Hero

$17.95
With sauteed onions and mozzarella cheese.

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

$12.95

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hero

$14.95

Shrimp Parmigiana Hero

$17.50

Sausage & Peppers Parmigan Hero

$13.50
Meatball Parmigiana Hero photo

Meatball Parmigiana Hero

$13.25

Meatball & Sausage Parmigiana Hero

$13.50

Sausage & Pepper Parmigiana Hero

$13.25

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero

$13.95

Pasta Sides

Fettucine Alfredo Pasta Side

$14.95

Fettucine Alfredo with Broccoli Pasta Side

$15.95

Clam Sauce Pasta Side

$16.95

Meat Sauce Pasta Side

$13.50

Pesto Sauce Pasta Side

$14.95

Marinara Sauce Pasta Side

$11.50

Penne Alla Vodka Pasta Side

$13.95

Side Dishes

Grilled Veggies

$12.25
Eggplant, zucchini, red onion, broccoli, tomato, roasted peppers.

Fries

$4.00
Waffles or Shoe String.

Onion Rings

$4.50

Meatballs or Sausage

$7.25
2 meaballs in pomodoro sauce | *Contains pork

Vegetable of the Day

$8.25
Spinach or Broccoli (sauteed vegetables extra).

Lite Delites

Grilled Chicken Breast Platter

$16.50
With choice of steamed vegetable (Grilled or Sautéed).

Grilled Shrimp & Vegetable Platter

$18.95
Over risotto with eggplant, zucchini, roasted peppers & tomato.

Spinach Chicken Delite

$14.95
Served on baby-leaf spinach with bacon bits, hard-boiled egg, roasted peppers & diced cucumbers.

Veggie Mesclun Salad

$14.50
With avocado, tomatoes, grilled eggplant, roasted peppers over mesclun greens.

Grilled Eggplant

$14.95
On Italian rustic bread with tomato, fresh mozzarella & balsamic marinated mesclun greens, served with house salad.

Soups

Onion Soup photo

Onion Soup

$6.50/+
12 oz $6.50 | 16 oz $7.50

Zuppa Del Giorno Soup

$4.25/+
12 oz $4.25 | 16 oz $6.75
Onion Au Gratin Soup photo

Onion Au Gratin Soup

$7.10/+
Small $7.10 | Large $8.10

Salads

Mini Caesar Salad

$5.25

Pauls Homemade Bottled Dressing

$7.25/+
Caesar $7.25 | Italian $7.25 | Ranch $8.95 | Blue Cheses $8.95

House Salad

$5.25
Mixed with greens with cucumber, carrots, tomato & croutons.

Double House Salad

$9.75

Grande Mozzarella Salad

$13.50
Mozzarella, tomato and cucumber.
Caesar Salad photo

Caesar Salad

$9.25
With homademade croutons and grated romano cheese mixed with romaine lettuce.

The Eastender Salad

$18.95
Grilled chicken & beef stir fry over diced romaine with tomatoes, cucumbers, crisp tortillas, avocado in our Caesar dressing with fried onions & crumbled hard boiled egg.

Greek Salad

$13.95
Feta cheese and Greek olives.
Fresh Mozzarella Salad photo

Fresh Mozzarella Salad

$14.95
With sun dried tomatoes, roasted peppers and black olive served over our mixed green salad | With Prosciutto Di Parma +$4.00 extra

Gorgonzola Salad

$14.95
On mesclun lettuce with roasted peppers, croutons and kalamata olives.

Chef's Salad

$15.75
Roast beef, ham, turkey, American and Swiss cheese with hard boiled egg & raw onion.

Menu

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$13.95

Southwestern Wrap

$13.25
Grilled chicken pepperoncini, salsa & mixed greens.

Teriyaki Shrimp Wrap

$17.25
Sauteed onions, roasted peppers & mixed greens.

Paul's Steak Wrap

$16.95
Marinated shell steak strips with sauteed peppers and onions with mozzarella cheese.

Teriyaki Chicken Wrap

$13.95
With avocado and tomato and mixed greens with teriyaki chicken.

Veggie Whole Wheat Wrap

$13.50
Grilled eggplant with avocado, roasted peppers, tomatoes & mixed greens with balsamic vinaigrette.

Teriyaki Quesadilla

$13.95/+
Sauteed peppers and onions with melted cheddar and mozzarella served with salsa and sour cream • With Chicken $13.95 | With Shrimp $16.95

Menu

Lemon Sarbet

$6.75

Biscotti

$0.80
Cannoli photo

Cannoli

$6.10
Chocolate Mouse photo

Chocolate Mouse

$6.25
Amaretto, Kahlua, hot chocolate, coffee.
Cheese Cake photo

Cheese Cake

$6.10
Kahlua, brandy and coffee.
Tiramisu photo

Tiramisu

$5.95
Frangelico, Kahlua, hot chocolate, coffee.
Tartufo photo

Tartufo

$6.10
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs